The Other Half of the Plan: The Biopsychosocial Side of Investing

A plan is only as good as the person carrying it out

Every advisor has seen it. The allocation is sound, the withdrawal rate is conservative, the Monte Carlo results are comfortable. Then the market drops 20 percent, and the client calls wanting out. Or the client who could afford to retire keeps working for years because it never feels like enough.

These are not math problems. They are human problems, and a growing body of research suggests they deserve as much attention as the portfolio itself. This is the biopsychosocial side of investing.

Mental health outweighs physical health

The University of Michigan’s Health and Retirement Study (HRS) has tracked the health and finances of tens of thousands of Americans over age 50 for three decades.

Dr. Chet Bennetts’ 2024 analysis points to a striking result. In every wave of HRS data, mental health’s effect on financial well-being was at least four times that of physical health, and in some years more than ten times.¹ That runs against intuition. We tend to see a serious diagnosis as the biggest threat to a retiree’s finances.

The practical reading is simple. Anxiety, depression and stress are not side issues to a financial plan. They sit close to its center.

Feeling secure matters more than being wealthy

In Dr. Bennetts’ model, how secure people felt about their money was the part most closely tied to overall financial well-being (standardized loadings of 0.74 to 0.85 across waves). Net worth (0.47 to 0.58) and income (0.48 to 0.53) mattered, but only moderately.²

Two clients with identical balance sheets can live very different financial lives. One sleeps well and spends with confidence. The other checks balances daily, delays purchases they can easily afford and reads every headline as a threat. On paper they are the same client. In practice, they need very different plans.

This also explains why more money does not always fix the problem. As Dr. Bennetts notes, people can feel financially secure “even if their income or assets are not the highest among their peers.”³ Confidence, clarity and trust in the plan often do more than additional assets.

The biopsychosocial lens

Medicine has long used a biopsychosocial model: health is shaped by biology, psychology and social context working together. The same lens fits investing.

  • Biological: age, health status, energy and cognitive changes affect time horizons, risk capacity and how much complexity a client can manage.
  • Psychological: money beliefs, past experiences, anxiety and loss aversion shape how a client reacts when markets move or a big decision arrives.
  • Social: family obligations, a spouse’s views, adult children, community and identity all influence what a client values and how they spend.

Traditional planning handles the first category reasonably well through longevity and health-cost assumptions. The HRS findings point squarely at the second: the psychological side deserves far more weight than it usually gets.

Where structure meets psychology: the Portfolio Waterfall

Some of that weight can be built into the structure of the portfolio. The Portfolio Waterfall provides a mental framework for retirement income. Instead of selling investments to fund income, the portfolio’s own cash flows (dividends, interest and capital gains) are harvested into a cash allocation. Withdrawals come from that cash, while the core investment units stay in place. While this cash-flow structure is designed to help investors manage behavioral reactions during market volatility, core investment values will still fluctuate, and this strategy cannot guarantee a profit or protect against loss in declining markets.

A client who understands that their income comes from what the portfolio produces, not from selling shares, has less reason to react when prices fall. In my experience, clients who understand this structure worry about market downturns less than clients who think of their income as dependent on market performance. That is the perceived security the HRS data links to financial well-being, built into the portfolio.

Modeling the person, not just the portfolio

For advisors, the implications are concrete:

  1. Ask about feelings, not just figures. How confident does the client feel about their money? What keeps them up at night? Their answers are data.
  2. Track perceived security over time. A plan that improves the numbers but not the client’s sense of security has not fully worked.
  3. Build plans clients can live with. The best allocation on paper is worth little if the client abandons it in a downturn. Structures like the waterfall help clients see why they don’t need to.
  4. Know when to bring in others. When stress, grief or family conflict is driving decisions, a referral to a counselor or therapist can protect the plan as much as any rebalancing.

Dr. Chet Bennetts sums it up: modeling the portfolio without modeling the person covers only half of the job. The numbers tell us what a client can do. The person tells us what they will do. Good planning needs both.


[1] Chet Richard Bennetts, ” Biopsychosocial Determinants of Financial Well-Being inOlder Adults: A Structural Equation Modeling Approach ” (PhD diss., Kansas StateUniversity, 2024), 151–52.

[2] Bennetts, “Biopsychosocial Determinants,” 148–50.

[3] Ibid., 149.


Disclosure

The views expressed herein reflect the views of Joshua L. Curtis / Gestalt Financial Group as of the date referenced and may change as conditions change. This information is provided as general information and should not be construed as individualized investment, tax, or legal advice.

Josh Curtis

Managing Member, Gestalt Financial Group